When Survivor premiered back in 2000, CBS had no clue that dropping 16 strangers on an island and offering $1 million to whoever could make it to the end would become a huge franchise that would change live TV forever. But getting to that finish line is where things get messy, as you’d have to convince people you’ve stabbed in the back to vote in your favor.
Here are the 10 most dramatic and controversial moments that explain why Survivor continues to captivate audiences.
View 6 photos
View 6 photos
View 6 photos
View 6 photos1. Jonny Fairplay fakes his grandmother’s death
Before getting dropped at Pearl Islands, Jon Dalton, better known as Jonny Fairplay, made a plan with his friend Dan. If Dan got to come out for the “loved ones’ visit,” he’d tell Fairplay that his grandmother had died.
Dan delivered the news, and the other players felt so bad for Fairplay that they let him win the challenge and spend more time with his friend. As it turns out, his grandmother was alive and would live until 2025. What else could you expect from a guy who calls himself “Fairplay”?
2. Jeff Varner outs Zeke Smith at Tribal Council
Facing elimination on Game Changers, Jeff Varner decided to tell the group that their fellow contestant Zeke Smith was transgender. Varner expected this move to paint Smith as deceptive, but the players immediately called Jeff out.
The reaction was so decisive that Probst dispensed with the formal vote and sent Varner home. Varner later apologized. The episode drew attention well beyond Survivor as viewers discussed Smith’s right to share that part of his life on his own terms.
3. Kellee Kim speaks up about unwanted touching
On Island of the Idols, Kellee Kim raised concerns about fellow contestant Dan Spilo repeatedly touching her without her consent. Kim was voted out, and Spilo stayed in the game until producers removed him near the end of the season following a separate off-camera incident.
The timing was really bad for the show, as the viewers had already watched Kim speak up and leave while Spilo was allowed to keep playing. The season ended with a departure from the usual format, too. The reunion was taped ahead of time instead of airing live.
4. Sue Hawk delivers her “snakes and rats” speech
The first Survivor finale provided future contestants with a clear understanding of what to expect when facing the jury. Sue Hawk called finalist Richard Hatch a snake and Kelly Wiglesworth a rat, and not in a cute way. Then she told Wiglesworth that if she ever found her dying of thirst, she’d leave her for the vultures. That’s some proper TV drama!
5. Cook Islands splits its tribes by race
For its 13th season, Survivor introduced four starting tribes, but for some reason, grouped them by race and ethnicity. As expected, CBS faced significant backlash before viewers had a chance to see how the situation would unfold. In the end, the season was pretty fun to watch, especially after the tribes were reshuffled.
6. Boston Rob proposes to Amber on live TV
By the All-Stars finale in 2004, Rob Mariano and Amber Brkich were crushing on each other and made it to the final two. Before the winner was announced, Rob bent the knee and proposed on camera. Amber said yes, of course, and then found out she’d won the million dollars. What a fantastic double whammy for Amber. The two went on to marry and have four daughters.
7. Ciera Eastin votes against her own mom
Blood vs. Water brought returning players back with loved ones, which meant a family visit could end with somebody writing down your name. Ciera Eastin did exactly that to her own mother, Laura Morett. She joined the majority that voted Laura out, prioritizing her own game over keeping her mother around. The subsequent family dinners must have been incredibly uncomfortable.
8. Liz Wilcox loses it over Applebee’s
Applebee’s was part of Liz Wilcox’s Wednesday-night Survivor routine back home. On Survivor 46, she got a shot at having it on the show itself. Then Q Burdette snatched that win and picked other people to go. It sounds like a nothingburger until you find out that Liz had allergies to things like coconut and other island food, which limited what she could eat at camp. When asked how she felt, Liz lost it, giving us this legendary meltdown.
9. J.T. Thomas gives his immunity idol to the enemy
On Heroes vs. Villains, J.T. thought an all-women’s alliance was targeting Russell Hantz. To save Russell, he gave him a hidden immunity idol that could protect him from elimination. What he didn’t know was that Russell was already working with the people J.T. thought were after him. After giving the other side a huge advantage, J.T. was later ruthlessly voted out.
10. Jeff Probst spoils his own finale
During the live Survivor 50 finale, Jeff Probst identified Rizo Velovic as the last juror before airing the fire-making challenge that knocked him out. This little slip-up told viewers everything they needed to know about who the winner was going to be. Probst humorously suggested that the show had provided everyone with a glimpse into the future, then, maintaining a serious demeanor, played the footage of the result he had just revealed.
